Keto vs Atkins - So what's the difference?
If we were to rank the most popular low-carb diets, the keto diet and the Atkins diet would be closely competitive. According to Megan Armstrong, RD, a clinical dietitian at Beaumont Health Weight Control Center in Canton, Michigan, both diets revolve around limiting carbohydrate intake and prioritizing protein and fat as energy sources.
These diets go beyond simply reducing consumption of carb-heavy foods that are detrimental to health, such as processed treats like donuts, cupcakes, and cookies. They also involve restricting certain fruits and vegetables. The primary objective of such strict carbohydrate limitation is to induce a state of ketosis in the body. Ketosis occurs when the body shifts from its usual fuel source, glucose (a type of sugar), to burning fat for energy. As carbohydrates are easily converted into glucose, depleting these stores forces the body to utilize fat.
Despite their shared emphasis on carb restriction, the keto diet and Atkins diet possess notable distinctions. It is important to be aware of these differences if you are contemplating a low-carb approach. Here are some key aspects to consider regarding each diet.
shop keto beef jerky on Amazon
How does the Atkins Diet Work: An Overview
The Atkins diet was introduced in 1972 by cardiologist Robert Atkins and has experienced periods of popularity since then. The original version, now referred to as Atkins 20, consists of four distinct phases. The initial phase, which is the most restrictive, sets the tone for the diet.
On the Atkins diet, protein and fat are considered acceptable, while carbohydrate consumption is strictly limited to approximately 20-25 grams of net carbs (total carbs minus fiber) during the introductory phase. These carbs mainly come from sources like nuts, seeds, vegetables, and cheese. This significant reduction in carb intake triggers a rapid response in the body. According to Armstrong, if you stick to the recommended carb restriction and avoid excessive protein intake, you are likely to enter a state of ketosis during the first phase. It's important to note that consuming excessive protein can hinder ketosis. The introductory phase continues until you are about 15 pounds away from your desired weight.
The second phase of the Atkins diet doubles the daily carb allowance, increasing it from 25 to 50 grams. This phase introduces foods like blueberries, cottage cheese, and yogurt. You remain in this phase until you are approximately 10 pounds away from your goal weight.
In the third phase, you gradually increase your net carb intake to a range of 50-80 grams. The goal is to find the optimal balance where weight loss is maintained without stalling. Michelle Jaelin, RD, a blogger at NutritionArtist.com based in Hamilton, Ontario, Canada, explains that this phase involves a slow and realistic process of trial and error to determine the amount of carbs that can be reintroduced without causing weight gain.
Once you have successfully established this balance and maintained it for one month, you transition to phase four, known as lifetime maintenance. This phase focuses on sustaining the habits developed during phase three. Carbohydrates are allowed, with an upper limit of around 100 grams per day, as long as weight regain is avoided.
shop keto beef jerky on Amazon
How does the Ketogenic Diet Work: An Overview
The ketogenic diet, often referred to as the keto diet, is a low-carbohydrate, high-fat diet that is designed to shift the body's metabolism into a state of ketosis. Ketosis is a natural metabolic process where the body primarily uses fat as its main source of fuel instead of carbohydrates. Here is an overview of how the ketogenic diet works:
The fundamental principle of the ketogenic diet is to significantly reduce carbohydrate intake and replace it with healthy fats. By minimizing carbs, typically to less than 50 grams per day, the body is deprived of its primary energy source, glucose derived from carbohydrates. As a result, it begins to break down stored fats into molecules called ketones, which are then utilized as an alternative energy source.
When carbohydrates are limited, insulin levels decrease, prompting the body to release stored fatty acids from adipose tissue. These fatty acids are transported to the liver, where they are converted into ketones. Ketones can cross the blood-brain barrier and provide energy to the brain, replacing glucose as a fuel source. This metabolic shift from carbohydrates to fats for energy production is the core mechanism of the ketogenic diet.
Achieving and maintaining ketosis is key to reaping the benefits of the ketogenic diet. It typically takes a few days to a week of strict carbohydrate restriction for the body to deplete its glycogen stores and enter ketosis. During this time, some individuals may experience the "keto flu," a temporary set of symptoms that may include fatigue, headaches, and brain fog as the body adapts to the new energy source.
The ketogenic diet emphasizes the consumption of high-quality fats, such as avocados, nuts, seeds, olive oil, and fatty fish, while moderating protein intake. This helps ensure that the majority of calories come from fats, enabling the body to sustain ketosis. It's important to note that the ketogenic diet requires careful planning and monitoring, as it can be challenging to maintain the necessary balance of macronutrients and micronutrients.
While the ketogenic diet has gained popularity for its potential benefits in weight loss, it has also been studied for its potential therapeutic effects in various health conditions, including epilepsy, type 2 diabetes, and metabolic syndrome. However, as with any diet, it's crucial to consult with a healthcare professional or registered dietitian before embarking on the ketogenic diet to ensure it aligns with your individual health goals and needs.
shop keto beef jerky on Amazon
Similarities Between the Keto and Atkins Diets
he keto diet and the Atkins diet, two popular low-carbohydrate approaches, share several similarities in their principles and effects. Here are some key similarities between the keto and Atkins diets:
Carbohydrate Restriction: Both the keto and Atkins diets emphasize a significant reduction in carbohydrate intake. They aim to limit the consumption of high-carb foods such as processed sugars, grains, and starchy vegetables. By restricting carbs, both diets seek to lower insulin levels and shift the body's metabolism towards utilizing fat for fuel.
Ketosis: Both diets strive to induce a state of ketosis in the body. Ketosis occurs when carbohydrate intake is limited to the point where the body starts producing ketones as an alternative energy source. In ketosis, the body primarily burns fat for fuel, leading to potential weight loss and increased fat metabolism.
High Fat and Protein Intake: Both diets emphasize the consumption of high-quality fats and adequate protein. They encourage the inclusion of foods such as avocados, fatty fish, nuts, seeds, and oils to provide essential fats and promote satiety. Protein intake is also important to support muscle maintenance and repair.
Phased Approach: Both the keto and Atkins diets often follow a phased approach to gradually increase carbohydrate intake over time. Atkins, specifically, has four phases that gradually introduce more carbohydrates as weight loss progresses. Similarly, the keto diet may allow for a slightly higher carb intake during maintenance phases after achieving ketosis.
Potential Health Benefits: Both diets have shown potential benefits beyond weight loss. They have been studied for their impact on improving blood sugar control, insulin sensitivity, and triglyceride levels. Additionally, both diets may have positive effects on certain health conditions, such as epilepsy and polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS).
While there are notable similarities between the keto and Atkins diets, it's important to recognize that there are also differences in their specific guidelines and recommended food choices. It is advisable to consult with a healthcare professional or registered dietitian to determine which diet aligns best with your goals, preferences, and individual health needs.
shop keto beef jerky on Amazon
Let us Look at the Differences Between the Keto and Atkins Diets
Here are the key differences between the keto and Atkins diets:
Carbohydrate Intake: The keto diet focuses on extremely low carbohydrate intake, typically below 20-50 grams per day, to achieve and maintain ketosis. In contrast, the Atkins diet allows for a gradual increase in carbohydrate intake throughout its phases, reaching up to 100 grams per day in the final phase.
Fat and Protein Ratio: The keto diet emphasizes a high-fat, moderate-protein intake, with approximately 75-80% of calories coming from fat. On the other hand, the Atkins diet offers more flexibility in fat and protein ratios, allowing individuals to adjust proportions based on their preferences and the specific phase of the diet.
Specific Food Emphasis: The keto diet encourages consuming healthy fats from sources like avocados, nuts, seeds, and oils, while also incorporating moderate amounts of protein. It restricts carbohydrate sources, including some fruits and vegetables. The Atkins diet has a broader range of food choices, including carbohydrate-rich foods like fruits, legumes, and specific vegetables, depending on the phase.
Phased Approach: The Atkins diet follows a structured, four-phase approach (induction, balancing, fine-tuning, and maintenance), gradually increasing carbohydrate intake as the individual progresses through the phases. The keto diet does not have predefined phases but focuses on maintaining nutritional ketosis as a long-term lifestyle.
Focus on Ketosis: Ketosis is a central aspect of the keto diet, aiming to shift the body's metabolism into a fat-burning state. The Atkins diet, while also promoting ketosis in its initial phase, places less emphasis on being in a constant state of ketosis and allows for higher carbohydrate consumption in later phases.
Remember that choosing between the keto and Atkins diets should be based on individual preferences, goals, and health considerations. Consulting with a healthcare professional or registered dietitian is recommended to determine the most suitable approach for your specific needs.
shop keto beef jerky on Amazon
Which Low-Carb Diet Is Safer, According to Dietitians?
When it comes to determining which low-carb diet is safer, it's important to note that individual health needs and goals play a significant role. However, dietitians generally consider the ketogenic diet (keto) to be more restrictive and potentially more challenging to follow in the long term compared to the Atkins diet. Here are some insights from dietitians regarding the safety of these diets:
Sustainability: Dietitians often highlight the importance of finding a sustainable eating plan. The Atkins diet, with its phased approach and gradual increase in carbohydrate intake, is generally viewed as more flexible and easier to sustain over time. The keto diet, with its strict carbohydrate limitation, may be more difficult to adhere to for extended periods, potentially leading to a higher likelihood of discontinuation.
Nutrient Adequacy: Both diets have the potential to be nutritionally adequate when properly planned. However, the restrictive nature of the keto diet may require careful attention to ensure sufficient intake of essential nutrients. The Atkins diet, with its broader food choices and phased approach, allows for a more varied nutrient intake, making it potentially easier to meet nutritional needs.
Individual Considerations: Dietitians stress the importance of considering individual health conditions and goals. The keto diet has shown therapeutic benefits in certain medical conditions, such as epilepsy and certain neurological disorders. However, it may not be suitable for everyone, especially individuals with certain medical conditions or specific dietary needs. The Atkins diet, with its more flexible approach, may be better suited for individuals with specific health considerations or those seeking a less restrictive eating pattern.
Long-Term Health Effects: The long-term effects of both diets are still being studied, and more research is needed to determine their overall impact on health. However, dietitians caution against prolonged adherence to very low-carb diets, as they may lead to potential nutrient deficiencies or imbalances if not carefully managed.
In summary, while both the keto and Atkins diets have their pros and cons, dietitians generally consider the Atkins diet to be a more flexible and potentially safer option due to its phased approach and wider range of food choices. However, it's essential to consult with a healthcare professional or registered dietitian who can assess your individual needs and provide personalized guidance on which low-carb diet is most suitable for you.
Comments
Post a Comment